5 Most Overrated Players in NBA 2K25
5. Ivica Zubac – 82 Overall
Ivica Zubac has long been a steady contributor for the Los Angeles Clippers, consistently playing a key role as their starting center. His ability to defend the paint, rebound, and finish around the rim makes him a valuable piece. However, in NBA 2K25, Zubac's rating of 82 seems a little too generous.
While Zubac is a solid player, he isn't elite in any one area. His scoring, defense, and rebounding are all good but not exceptional. Players like Isaiah Hartenstein, Nic Claxton, and Jalen Duren are rated just slightly lower, yet they have similar or, in some cases, better stats in crucial categories like rebounding, shot-blocking, and defensive impact. Zubac's consistency has been rewarded with an 82 overall rating, but realistically, his performance suggests he should be rated closer to 80.
4. Damian Lillard – 89 Overall
Damian Lillard has been one of the league's premier point guards for years, known for his deep shooting range and clutch play. However, in NBA 2K25, his rating of 89 feels too high, especially after a somewhat challenging season as the second option with the Milwaukee Bucks. His scoring dropped significantly, and his overall efficiency took a hit, reflecting his adjustment to a new role alongside Giannis Antetokounmpo.
When comparing Lillard to other point guards like De'Aaron Fox or Jamal Murray, both of whom had strong seasons but are rated slightly lower, it's clear that Lillard's reputation might be keeping his rating high. Fox had a breakout season, and Murray helped lead his team to playoff success, yet Lillard's rating remains higher, despite his dip in production.
Lillard is still a fantastic player, but a more fitting rating might be closer to 87 or 88, especially when compared to other elite point guards in the game.
3. Victor Wembanyama – 91 Overall
Victor Wembanyama, the highly touted rookie, had a remarkable debut season, showcasing his unique blend of size, skill, and defensive ability. The French star dominated both offensively and defensively in stretches, earning the Rookie of the Year award and putting up strong numbers for a first-year player. However, his 91 overall rating in NBA 2K25 seems to be more reflective of his potential rather than his current impact.
Despite his undeniable talent, Wembanyama led the San Antonio Spurs to just 22 wins, one of the worst records in the league. His shooting percentages, especially from three-point range, could use improvement, and he still has a lot to learn in terms of decision-making and consistency. Ranking Wembanyama above established stars like Ja Morant and Jimmy Butler feels premature, as these players have proven they can lead their teams deep into the playoffs.
Wembanyama's rating should be adjusted slightly lower, perhaps around 88, until he solidifies himself as a superstar capable of elevating his team's success.
2. Kyrie Irving – 92 Overall
Kyrie Irving remains one of the most talented and skilled point guards in the NBA. His handles, shooting touch, and ability to score in clutch moments are unparalleled. But in NBA 2K25, his rating of 92 seems too high when considering his current role on the Dallas Mavericks, where he plays alongside Luka Dončić, one of the league's top players. Being the second option has reduced some of the pressure on Irving, allowing him to be more efficient, but it also means his overall impact on the game has diminished slightly.
When you look at other guards in the 90 overall range, like Tyrese Haliburton or Ja Morant, it becomes clear that Irving's rating might be inflated due to his past achievements and his well-known skill set. Both Haliburton and Morant are focal points for their respective teams, whereas Irving shares the spotlight with Dončić.
Irving's rating should be closer to 90, reflecting his current standing in the NBA hierarchy as a phenomenal but not top-tier guard.
1. Jayson Tatum – 95 Overall
Jayson Tatum finally captured his first NBA championship in 2024, solidifying his place among the league's top players. He has consistently led the Boston Celtics deep into the playoffs throughout his career and signed a record-breaking supermax contract in the offseason. However, his 95 rating in NBA 2K25 seems inflated when you compare it to other players in that elite category.
While Tatum put up great numbers last season, his stats slightly declined due to the increased talent around him on the Celtics roster. Players like LeBron James and Stephen Curry, who are also rated 95, have similar statistics, but both have proven they can take over games in a way that Tatum hasn't quite done yet.
Tatum's rating is likely boosted by his recent championship and the fact that he's one of the cover athletes for NBA 2K25. However, a rating of 93 or 94 would be more in line with his actual performance compared to other legends with similar ratings.
In conclusion, while NBA 2K25 strives for accuracy in player ratings, there are always a few players who receive ratings that seem too high based on their recent performances. Whether you're looking to build your dream team or improve your MyPLAYER, it's important to be aware of these overrated players. If you're planning to buy NBA 2K25 MT or accumulating 2K25 MT to upgrade your team, keep these players in mind when managing your roster.